If it isn’t clear already, I am not a hijabi. But while other young Muslim women would express disapproval (in a not-so-keen patriarchal tactic of pitting women against each other) at the trope of the hijabi who goes clubbing with her friends and wears vivid makeup while simultaneously donning a “modest” persona, I would almost always immediately arrive at her defense. I love the stealth hijabi. Other than the fact that I don’t wear a headscarf, I am the stealth hijabi. I’m the woman who removes her pantyhose as soon as she walks out of her front door.
You see, the stealth hijabi doesn’t actually do anything wrong. She doesn’t drink or gamble or gossip—her biggest “shortcoming” is disobedience. (And dancing, apparently, but we’ll get to that in a different post.) She does not mean to be deceitful. Unlike her falsely attributed counterpart, the man who drinks and sleeps around yet demands a virgin wife, she does not impose her judgments on others or set double standards for the opposite sex.
Arguably this is a variety of the stealth hijabi—granted I never did sneak off to parties late at night. I did, however, go to the library in the afternoon on weekends while my mother, at work, had no idea, and also to the movies with friends I haven’t seen for a long time. And how did I justify this? It is not easy to lie to one’s mother, but the way I saw it, I was restoring something of mine that is a right, and something I needed from which I had been continuously obstructed. In my childhood I never went to sleepovers or hosted them, I didn’t see a movie in theaters until Pirates of the Caribbean 3 in high school, never went shopping with friends until university. None of these things are against Islam, but they are against the overprotective regulations of my mother, who cannot to this day allow me to run to the store alone.
To understand this, you should know two things. The first is that immigrant parents, though they come from countries that are a thousand times more dangerous than the US (or at least mine did), can not move past their fears of the unfamiliar to the reality that this nation is more foreign and foreboding to them than it is to their children. Though my mother knows from evidence that I can demonstrably get myself out of any situation, she’s convinced that I’ll be left stranded somewhere and she’ll have no way to reach me—even if that “somewhere” is less than ten miles away, and even if, had we resided in her country of birth, she would have allowed me to travel anywhere in the city I desired despite the higher risk.
The second is that I was abused as a child, and my mother also endured domestic violence.
Let me explain the resulting dynamics by starting from the beginning: When I was very little–about four to five years old–I would invent new toys from our old toys for my little brother (who was one to two at the time). He would wake up from his nap and play with them. When he tired of them I would take them apart and make new toys again, and he would return to playing with them with new interest. When my mother was asleep I would sneak out with my brother and take him to the park and push him on the swings and we would run back home before my mom woke up. (Until she discovered, at which point we ceased.)
As we grew older we were growing accustomed to our little world–and it was an abusive one. Except the abuse didn’t stop with the perpetrator. I was very soft at school, attentive, responsive, bright–at home I turned into a monster. I became extremely controlling. I stopped making things for my bother to play with–I took things from him instead. Especially if these things were books I wanted to read, or time on the computer (we only had one then), anything–anything!–that would allow me to escape. He needed to play too, but he was young. I was three years older and that means I had the power. And I used it.
I cried often. (So did he.) And I continued to take things from him, because if because of the abuse I couldn’t have control over myself then I had to have control over someone else! In a few long years my brother watched the sister who had told him stories and made things for him to play with and never yelled at him even once and made excuses for him when he broke something or made a mess turn into someone absolutely unjust that he was forced to hate.
Eventually, I learned to live with what was happening to both of us (an opportunity my brother never had because he had no way to act out), and I came back around again. (“We all return to our nature,” my mother once said.) But the damage was done.
Although I was always aware of the devastating irony that my mother did not want me to leave the house in fear that some danger would befall me when in fact my own house was the most dangerous place I could be, it took me a long time to realize that my obsessive controlling nature toward my brother as a result of the abuse was almost exactly like the overprotective nature of my mother toward us. (She was much kinder though, and genuinely was afraid she would lose me to a world of kidnappers and murderers.) I have no doubt that she already had the inclination to be overprotective, all factors considered, and overprotection is not intrinsically a negative thing that stunts the joys of childhood, but had we not been in this position, she would have been freer and more open with allowing us to participate in regular activities of which childhood is composed. And indeed, as the atmosphere of our lives shifted, she began to accept that she couldn’t supervise me at all times–and shouldn’t.
The reacquisition of my freedom, and the right to live my life, was something I deserved, something I saw–and still see–as rightfully mine, the retribution of a deprived childhood.
Those who insist that Muslim women who engage in supposedly religiously dubious activities whilst modestly dressed are championing a façade of modesty are as mistaken as those who insist it is just an “expected” natural rebellion against the restraints of an intensely confined society that does not allow them freedom. Both these allegations fail to compassionately approach the structural complexity of subverting two patriarchies and neglect to recognize the stealth hijabi—and the Muslim woman—as an agent fully seizing her opportunities and her personhood to play the system and restore her rights within her Moral framework. The approach of the stealth hijabi to life is a careful and restorative one, and not the irresponsible “damaged beyond redemption” state that Muslims suppose or the simple “rebellious child” that non-Muslims perceive.
The woman taking off her pantyhose as she walks out of her house isn’t intentionally duplicitous. Nor is she a helpless thing to be saved who is slipping out of one patriarchy and stepping into another. She is fully conscious of her identity, a lover of beauty and of quiet pleasures; she may arguably be a coward for avoiding confrontation—or she may be too tired to give a damn anymore.
There is a point of recognizing that not only is there no explanation owed, there is no time to deliver one.
And while I can understand, as a woman who does not wear a headscarf, the bitter temptation to disparage a hijabi praised by patriarchal society by magnifying her “falsity,” I simply refuse to engage in deriding any of my sisters.
17 thoughts on “The Stealth Hijabi”
“I simply refuse to engage in deriding any of my sisters.”
One of the many reasons I love you so.
You are back to writing a lot :) so happy.
Wait….you and your brother are friends again, though, right? Please don’t break my heart and say it ain’t so…
Welcome back, you have been missed.
LOL Yes we are. Not quite the same though. He always wants me to hang around and watch movies but I always shoot down any show of affection with sarcastic remarks. X_x
I do the same thing with my little brother and the rest of my family. I keep them a bit distant. In my case it’s partly avoidance because social situations make me anxious (even in my own family). I feel that if I engage with him I’ll be obliged to spend ages with him and I’ll feel trapped. I dislike the cost of missing out on the relationship, though. I tell myself that I can spend just ten minutes with him and leave any time I want to. Usually once I get chatting to him it’s easy. That helps me, not sure if it’d work for you.
That’s how it is with me, except that I’m always preoccupied about how I can possibly return to how I was before after all that’s happened as if I could just expect it be forgotten.
Thank you for sharing an intimate piece of yourself. You are so appreciated. I like being allowed into your world bit by bit.
I am lucky to know you Sarah.
I’m really thankful for knowing you,Nahidah! While everyone is quick to judge hijabi women,you have opted to do the thing that is more difficult and better to do.Love you girl! That’s the way to go.And thank God I can see your blog again :)
I hope you can see my earlier comment.Love you girl!
Yes, I can see it. =) Thank you so much Lat!
Thank you so much for writing this; I currently face the same dilemma over my freedom and right to go out at night and hang out with friends WITHOUT asking my father (or a husband, as my mom claims) for permission. As someone who loves heavy metal music, and enjoys going to concerts, it never ceases to frustrate and wear me down whenever my own family (parents and even an uncle) say that I’m misguided and naive for wanting to do this. They constantly try to shove their own religious values down my throat so they could ban me from going to shows, and at one point even resorted to ganging up on me at the same time. That some (non-Muslim, non-metal loving) idiots reacted to my story by laughing in my face when I told them doesn’t exactly help things for me, either!
I’m so happy to come across your blog and see something that directly addresses my dilemma and situation to a T. I’m fed up of being encouraged to second guess myself, and take on my parents’ cultural values as religion when they are clearly not. Thank you.
I guess as women we can never win!
Though I have to say women who do not wear hijab or do it ‘incorrectly’ or horror of all horrors de-hijabed tend to face the most harsh and unpleasant comments.
Its each woman’s personal choice but I weary of hearing the same tired and unconvincing lectures on how its a choice (but an obligatory one–that does not even make any sense!), its supposed anti-rape properties and women who do not wear it are rebellious and deserve any and all evil that befalls them.
Sorry for the rant —but this woman shame and blame game really infuriates me. Especially when its completely unending and even when women do opt for hijab–they still are not cut any slack and petty comments are made on make-up (way too much or she has really let herself go), clothing (too trendy or too frumpy) or their just wanting to have some fun is illicit.
When does it all end.
Thanks for sharing – this is absolutely beautiful (and I’m now trying not to try in a crowded Starbucks – that’s what I get for checking my RSS feed in public!).
I can relate to you on so many levels! I am also not a hijabi, even though I have considered it- but then I questioned myself- Am I going to do it for the right reasons? Am I doing it for God, myself or society? Or worse, for a man? I’ve heard it’s a process, internal to external. If you improve your deen and character, that reflects through the hijab. Honestly it’s not my place to judge, but I don’t even know why a lot of women out there even wear the hijab when they have terrible personalities and habits. It’s pointless!
Ya know, I hate that line of thinking that wearing hijab equates to being a nun. Especially hate it when so many women have social pressure to wear hijab and do it to conform, not because it has some magical, special significance in her life. I especially adore hijabis who smoke cigarettes… but that’s just me. :)
LOL! I love hijabis with “terrible personalities.” =X
Nahida, I really, really appreciated your post. I recently wrote a post entitled ‘I am not a hijabi’; I googled the phrase afterward and came across your post and am thankful for that. I hope you don’t mind I’ve shared your post in a couple different places to share another perspective involving this phrase. Looking forward to following your blog and reading more.